NWB - Community Blog

Avatar

Covers, Originals or Both

Filed Under : Music

Posted By : Scott - Metalleeka | Comments : 17

Just wanting to see what the general consesnus is with regards to fitting your original compostions into gigs.


Hey guys
Just looking for a bit of advice.

Basically at the moment, we have 13 covers and 4 orginals finished with 3 or 4 nearly done.
The band are eager to get out gigging although some of the guys in the band are wanting to throw 3 or 4 of our own songs into the setlist.

This is where I'm hoping some of you guys have had experience in this area.
Do we get the gig on the pretence that we're a covers band and slip in a few originals?
Do we ask permission to play originals first?
Do we look for 2 seperate gigs? One for our covers and another purely originals setlist?

Do you know any venues that are happy to put on originals bands and pay them in the process? (obviously not at the same rate as covers bands, but at least something for all the trouble would be nice)

Cheers

Scott


Comments

Avatar
 
# Posted by delete 79 - 02/03/2009, 11:09 (GMT)

hiya m8, we used to be in exactly the same position. we started as a covers band and then began writing some of our own stuff. even though it might not have been the best material in the world we were proud of it and started puuting it straight into the live set. however we soon found the venues that in we were playing (pubs mainly) it was just lost on people. when people go and watch a band in a pub they generally wanna have a good time and singalong to songs that they know. there are noticable exceptions but they are few and far between. my advice is to stick to playing your own stuff at specific venues where original artists are welcomed. we've since dropped all original material from pub gigs and noticed in massive difference in crowd reaction. hope this helps. ben - the fix


Avatar
 
# Posted by Scott - Metalleeka - 02/03/2009, 11:21 (GMT)

cool, sort of what I was thinking, although, can I ask, was it purely based on crowd reaction that the decision was made to drop the originals and not the landlords?
Cos if that's the case, then it may be worth just trying a couple and seeing if they go down well or go down like an elephant on a snowboard lol


Avatar
 
# Posted by Angel Of Sin - 02/03/2009, 11:42 (GMT)

Most landlords on the covers circuit in Yorkshire are happy for a GOOD band to do just a few of their own songs. For example Motus do 3-4 of their own. Just be prepared for them to possibly not go down well with most punters.


Avatar
 
# Posted by delete 79 - 02/03/2009, 12:29 (GMT)

hey scott yeah our decision was solely based on the crowd reaction. we never had a landlord mention anything about original stuff at all. but more than a few times when we went to drop our posters in at venues a few weeks before they were printed up with "playing covers and originals" and when the regulars saw them they couldnt wait to start salgging us off!!! however if your confident in your stuff give it a go, everyones gotta start somewhere!!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by NIGHT TRAIN - 02/03/2009, 12:31 (GMT)

thing to do is, in pubs, do covers mainly and then stick maybe a couple of originals in (one each set)....if you play the gig regular then the audience will get to know em. Gradually you can introduce more.
Speaking with my other head on...I also run acoustic open mic sessions and ran the north west songwriting competition for several years....and if I'm honest (no disrespect to anyone on here cos I aint heard any of you doing original stuff) what the songwriter thinks is a good song and what the audience thinks is worth listening to are two different matters! LOL

A lot of musicians 'write' songs that frankly aren't very good...and I include myself here...the writer thinks they're good but no-one else does. I once met a girl who told me quite openly that she had written more than a thousand songs...and she was only around 28 years old
! Now bearing in mind that Lennon & McCartney only wrote around 100 , and Bob Dylan's only written about 500 in nearly 50 years...thats some claim.

We're basically a blues based rock band...we can take our pick from thousands and thousands of old blues songs, and if we wanted say we'd written em...nobody would ever know, but even then we'd be in trouble if we didn't do certain standards or did a whole night of obscure stuff.

Look at it another way...if you go to see your favourite artist in concert you'd be really pissed off if they just did two hours of stuff you'd never heard before. I like Dylan, but if he did a full show of brand new numbers I'd miss some of the classics. And that would be in a concert situation....at a pub gig where you don't concentrate fully on the music anyway cos there's other things going on, that would be even harder to take.

I guess it all boils down to why you're playing in a band anyway...I do it for the laugh..its fun!If you're serious about being a recording band then pub gigs aren't for you anyway. There's an awful lot of people who write songs, and an awful lot of people who write songs that really aint worth a bean...and there's very few (even from professional songwriters) that I would like to spend an evening listening to in a pub....unless I'd first heard them and familiarised myself with them at home.

Just slip the odd one in both sets see how they go, and take it from there.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Scott - Metalleeka - 02/03/2009, 12:32 (GMT)

too be honest, our style is only going to be suited to rock pubs and clubs anyway, and our original material is very similar in style to the stuff we play anyway, so I would hope they would go down well, but until we try them we'll never know.

thx guys
Scott


Avatar
 
# Posted by NIGHT TRAIN - 02/03/2009, 12:44 (GMT)

I know one band...not on here yet, but I still won't name em...who did all originals...they were really catchy numbers, but then after a while I realised they'd just picked a good song eg a ZZ Top one, slightly altered the arrangement and stuck new words to it. They'd done em all like that...so you'd get say ...Whole lotta Rosie, slightly different and revamped, then a Motorhead one, slightly different etc etcetc. And they got away with it for years :o)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Scott - Metalleeka - 02/03/2009, 12:55 (GMT)

lol
the main reason I left without reason was that whilst I wanted to play all the classic metal covers from the likes of Priest, Maiden, Metallica, Queensryche etc, I had a few songs that I had written over the years and when the band picked a couple of them to actually do, you couldn't wipe the smile off me face everytime we practiced them. Now, I'd like to just try them on stage, if they don't work, which let's face it, there's a 95% chance that they'll go down poorly, then at least I'll have had the buzz of giving it a go.

Like you said Nighttrain, it's all about having fun. I'm getting too old now for the dreams of rock superstardom lol




Avatar
 
# Posted by mr.nwb - 02/03/2009, 13:02 (GMT)

Alec, that Thai Bird Flu Blues song you wrote was amazing!

Do you still play it?

I think originals can be played at "pub gigs", they just have to be uber amazing/ humourous/ attention grabbing, otherwise people just use the time to get another round of drinks in, or off for a ciggie.


Avatar
 
# Posted by delete 79 - 02/03/2009, 13:04 (GMT)

amen night trains earlier comment. the amount of bands that you speak to and theyve writtend over a hundred songs for their next deme when you hear them and you realise all 100 are shite!!!
i like listening to bands live, be it covers or originals but i havent heard a band play a decent original tune for about 5 years now.
if i hear another daft band singing about his ex girlfriend or just blatently ripping off oasis etc im gonna go mad.
theres one quite big local band who i wont name and every single one of their tunes is a fucking stone roses or smiths rip off! it does my head in!!!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by mr.nwb - 02/03/2009, 13:08 (GMT)

Does this band have a small amp, per chance?


Avatar
 
# Posted by NIGHT TRAIN - 02/03/2009, 13:24 (GMT)

"Alec, that Thai Bird Flu Blues song you wrote was amazing!

Do you still play it?"

I deny all knowledge of said song, your honour! LOL


Avatar
 
# Posted by delete 79 - 02/03/2009, 13:25 (GMT)

no mr nwb. and i wont be dragged into naming names as ive already been on the wrong side of this band in the past and its not pretty!!!!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Duke Bocks - 02/03/2009, 17:22 (GMT)

a wise man once said to me.. "PEOPLE DON'T ALWAYS KNOW WHAT THEY LIKE...BUT THEY WILL ALWAYS LIKE WHAT THEY KNOW"...thanks dad


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 02/03/2009, 20:03 (GMT)

scott-there are two bands on here-furyuk and decadenze, both consisting of, relatively, young musos-who have followed night "trians"(!) words of wisdom. by mixing in some covers with their own material they are now both well on their way to being major players on the circuit.my personal opinion, from being on both sides of the mic, is that a 60/40 split in favour of covers seems to be about right at first, then, as you gain ground, fit one or two more of your own in/? :-)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Coldplayer - 04/03/2009, 14:34 (GMT)

I don't see the point in doing both me. Listening to original music you've not heard before challenges the listener, something that cover band audiences aren't really after. I might be wrong, but I'm getting this from the fact that when we play a pub-style venue and run through some lesser known U2 numbers, even if we've given the performance of our lives sometimes people barely muster a clap!
For me cover bands are an extended version of a DJ, they want to hear the tracks they know.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Elias.T.Hoth - 04/03/2009, 21:02 (GMT)

Do all your own orginal material and fuck em!if you really do believe in it? there the rub?

you wont get many gigs but the one's you do get you will always remember!!

be yourself and express yourself, be passionate and be known for what you really are and what you say

It matters in the end if only to yourself!

elias.t.hoth


back to top

Blog Search

Follow NWB on Facebook and Twitter

Cottam Guitars

10% Discount for NWB members, email max@cottamguitars.co.uk

Bakehouse Studio

Accrington's cosy project studio. Book online 24/7. Use code NWB20bc110301 for NWB members special 20% discount.

Community Blog Guidelines

  1. Be nice: Even if you disagree with someone, you need to keep your tone civil and reasonable.
  2. Keep on topic: Please keep discussions relevant to each topic and avoid multiple topic posts.
  3. Don't Spam: Show restraint with your posting frequency. We're all doing cool stuff on NWB, but if we post about it too much, it can be distracting.
  4. Respect the Moderators: The entire Community Staff were users once, just like you. We try very hard to answer everyone's questions, so please be cool.

PAT Testing

Pat Testing NW
Mention NWB when contacting