NWB - Community Blog

Avatar

Horses for Courses and all that...

Filed Under :

Posted By : 4most Wanted | Comments : 102

Possibly controversial but...................


Following on from an earlier blog about band names, I made a comment about a certain band that could be seen as derogatory but wasn't meant to be so.

In fact, there may be one or two musos on here that find my whole comment derogatory, but hey ho, you can't please all of the people all of the time.

Here is my comment:
"It may sound elitist or whatever, but when I was younger (teens in the 70's), I used to love bands like Free, Quo, Queen, Purple, Zeppelin, Sabbath etc.etc. but after hearing most of their songs played extremely badly over the years, I no longer want to listen to it. When I started learning bass, I used to love playing those songs, basically because that's all I could play, but as I started learning more about music, time signatures, key changes, global rhythms etc., that old stuff held no sway for me anymore. I wonder if there's any other muso's on here that can relate to what I'm trying to say."

I suppose I'm saying i've moved on, and tried to be more diverse in my playing, hence the reason I am no longer gigging because quite honestly, I would rather sit playing with myself than be subjected to playing the amount of garbage that would furnish me with a few extra beer tokens. But that's just me.

Points being, when I see the description "Classic rock band", wild horses could not drag me to their gig. But as I say "each to their own", "horses for courses", "one man's meat is another man's poison", (Mr. Mercury is testament to that) and every other cliche that one could use.

So, are there any other muso's that can relate to what I'm trying to say?

And if this blog goes tits up it's all Night Train's fault!

Comments

Avatar
 
# Posted by James - Metalleeka - 12/09/2011, 22:46 (GMT)

I can relate to what you are saying, but not necessarily for the same reasons. I began in the cabaret circuit at a tender age of 17 but it gradually eroded my soul, until 5 years ago when I decided to sell the remains to devil, and form a band playing music written in the fires of hades.

But if push came to shove, and truth be told, I'd rather be out playing any genre with other musos than stay home noodling


Avatar
 
# Posted by Keytek Audio Services - 12/09/2011, 22:50 (GMT)

I am only a young musician so my reply may not be through more life muso experience than other replies...but...

I find that Playing with the bands I have, I find myself looking for MORE than what the band scene offers as regards song choice and genre. I do like to play alone quietly enhancing my technique allround but to apply this into a gigging band would'nt seem to come around to often as everyone does seem to play the same "shit".

Soooo I look at it more this way...

I find that playing with my current band...yes...it has gotten boring and thats for all of us due to taking the crowd pleasing song choice option. BUT.. a lot of this was down to playing the same venues over and over. Same faces all the time at the same places. Obviously everyone just gets bored and ultimately so do we.

Since we have taken on new venues though, it is like playing a whole new set list. New faces and new sets of people enjoying us for the first time all over again. That is more appealing to me more than what songs we actually play. It makes me re-enjoy and sparks new enthusiasm for playing songs that we have by far KILLED over and over.

I do look forward to the day when my new found skills and technical ability get chance to shine though. But until then. Old borin shit it is haha

Hope thats not too off topic or totally nothing to do with what you have said lol







lucky


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 12/09/2011, 22:55 (GMT)

Well, where to start?...

If you find it boring to play, then you are going to bore people - so stop.

If what you play bores people - stop.

If you bore yourself - stop.

Am I boring you?

YAWN

STOP


Avatar
 
# Posted by 45's - 12/09/2011, 23:06 (GMT)

Have a look at our repertoire. It's pretty diverse I think and we've left so many "pop" songs off the list so as not to scare some " Dedecated Rock Venues" off. We can drop on these pop songs if we feel the clientele would appreciate them on the night. ( I'll pm them to you if you like ), lol.

Horses for courses, I whole heartedly agree in the set list / Venue respect if that makes sense,

Rick.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 12/09/2011, 23:06 (GMT)

W/Rick likes Erasure


Avatar
 
# Posted by 45's - 12/09/2011, 23:16 (GMT)

@ Rob Red, Shhhhhhhhhh ! Fook off, no I don't,

Wick.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 12/09/2011, 23:17 (GMT)

nothing up with that , 80s pop rules!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Defunct account - 12/09/2011, 23:25 (GMT)

I'm quite used to be slated or ignored so here goes....

My reading of this is that it is a suggestion that the overall scene (venues, bands and fans) covered by MWB is a little concentrated in one quite distinct area and that it would be nice to see some variation. This isn't a new theme. I've seen plenty of well-meaning folk be slated for making this suggestion. Whatever! It works for you or it don't - thats the horses for courses bit out of the way - but there's a question missing here...


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 12/09/2011, 23:27 (GMT)

its deja vu all over again.


Avatar
 
# Posted by 45's - 12/09/2011, 23:28 (GMT)

drum roll.................................,

Wick.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Wagontown - 12/09/2011, 23:29 (GMT)

Hi 4most,I think all of us muso's know what your saying,but it could be easily misread that you can play these songs better than anyone else.Dont give up ,get out there and show em how its done.What a waste of talent,just sitting there playing with yourself...your words not mine....T


Avatar
 
# Posted by 45's - 12/09/2011, 23:30 (GMT)

Rob, my Anne used Erasure stuff for her aerobic classes that she used to take. All 4's on the Bass Drum - perfect,

Wick.


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 12/09/2011, 23:37 (GMT)

@Alyerpal - what the fuck are you on about?

In answer to your statements above :
"If you find it boring to play, then you are going to bore people - so stop" - Yes I did

"If what you play bores people - stop" - I did, but half of the bands on here continue to do it.

"If you bore yourself - stop" - No I don't. As i've said, I diversify to rid myself of the bland and the mundane.

"Am I boring you?" - Indeed you are.

Apologies that this blog is not advertising your business, or praising your workmanship, but hey, they can't all be about you eh?


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 12/09/2011, 23:47 (GMT)

@Wagontown - That's the thing though Terry, I don't think I'm better than anybody else. If anything, i'd admit to being rather average but found I wasn't learning anything by playing the same songs/ same genre material.

I got sick of being the"dum dum" man and wanted to play other styles/genres. But try putting a band together to do it. As I've said in a previous blog, the Latin American version of Smoke on the water really floats my boat, but as another member pointed out - "Can't see you getting away with it in most North West pubs".

So a case of damned if you do, damned if you don't eh?


Avatar
 
# Posted by Defunct account - 12/09/2011, 23:57 (GMT)

The question's come up? So like quite a number of us lurkers you're basically saying you on the wrong course hoss ;-)

For what its worth I agree with you entirely - even Aesop put together a fable around this very issue - and maybe that's why we refer to our gigs as our "giving it to the bar staff tour" :-) Thing is in 2 and a half years we've crammed 300+ in. You want to do something different to most of the bands on here then do it, don't use their inertia as your excuse :-)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 13/09/2011, 00:01 (GMT)

so someone says - "Can't see you getting away with it in most North West pubs"
i would guess this someone has never been within an inch of a Latin American version of anything that wasn't Smooth

"You want to do something different to most of the bands on here then do it, don't use their inertia as your excuse"

ta daaaaaa

s'easy innit!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Blackjacks - 13/09/2011, 00:02 (GMT)

Take up free jazz and turn up to jam nights all the way round the north west, play what you like and off you pop problem sorted!!

Self indulgence check!!!

;-)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 13/09/2011, 00:03 (GMT)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Wagontown - 13/09/2011, 00:04 (GMT)

4most,Why couldnt you get away with it in a pub ?Just look at our setlist,and we have to follow classic rock bands ,blues bands,yet 75 % of the punters say ,what a refreshing change from the norm,if you can offer something different ,just get out there and do it....T


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 13/09/2011, 00:08 (GMT)

i smell garlic


Avatar
 
# Posted by Wagontown - 13/09/2011, 00:17 (GMT)

Sorry about the garlic,i Had a vindaloo at tea bristling with the stuff.Did i say what the other 25% said ?....T


Avatar
 
# Posted by MrNobody - 13/09/2011, 03:16 (GMT)

I'd agree with just do it and try it etc

The problem is finding other guys willing to do other styles other than the general same old same old. On this site and other sites ...there generally isn't many open minded guys.

I know of excellent players who now sit at home and join internet bands with guys from all round the world and have started to re-write covers or write/contribute to originals, rather than gig and put up with the general muso mind sets and gigging issues. After my current band that doesnt really gig in the typical nwb venues ends (dont know when that'll be ) - I too will be off doing the internet virtual band...cos I cant find anyone who would play Latin/Jazz/Funk/fusions etc.

One thing I learnt a long time ago - don't try changing other peoples mid sets, cos they just laugh at you...yet their the ones that play the same old numbers or can only play basic 3-chord tricks.

Good luck in your search !!

B



Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 13/09/2011, 08:10 (GMT)

"The problem is finding other guys willing to do other styles"

"I know of excellent players who now sit at home and join internet bands with guys from all round the world and have started to re-write covers or write/contribute to originals, rather than gig and put up with the general muso mind sets"

make your mind up!!

LOL


Avatar
 
# Posted by Wagontown - 13/09/2011, 09:19 (GMT)

Hi B please dont take this as ganging up on you,but what is 'A general muso mind set' ? Surely theres nothing more diverse than the guys on here,youve only to look at the rows and arguments....lol....T


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 11:25 (GMT)

Perhaps I am the most qualified to comment on this as it was my comments which have been quoted.

Firstly 4most Wanted - You should move to Darwen as there is a lot of musicians like myself who love playing something a bit different. It's just a case of finding those people. Look at my bands-

The Cottonhouse Shakers - jazz versions of Ace Of Spades, funked up Muddy Waters, swing versions of Hank Williams..... the list goes on and on.

The soultrain - Northern Soul - nobody else is doing it.

Shantytown Junction - Southern and Central African guitar based dance music - Now come on...who else?

There's another four bands that I play with that play - reggae, acoustic blues and a ceiledh band.

Yes, the classic rock band doesn't interest me to play however I still enjoy watching a good classic rock covers band. This can be backed up by the amount of bands on here that I've seen and enjoyed.


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 11:33 (GMT)

@Willow - i would guess this someone has never been within an inch of a Latin American version of anything that wasn't Smooth

Not sure what you mean by smooth, but I have played Latin styles before in Gone Beggin' and it is I who added the Senior Coconut track.

My point is that it is harder to get a gig in a venue which is used to classic rock if you play something different. I don't think that is an unrealistic comment and I'm not grumbling about that because landlords need to fill their pubs and if their regulars want classic rock then fair enough....who wouldn't?

None of my bands are particularly busy which is why I play in so many different line ups. This way I always get gig satisfaction and nothing becomes stale. It is however difficult to fit in the rehearsals!

Sit at home getting more satisfaction? Not for me.


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 11:37 (GMT)

As for Latin, I recently booked The Giddy Gringos for Darwen Jazz & Bues Festival. They are NWB members and are superb. They are based in Rochdale so look out for them!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 13/09/2011, 12:03 (GMT)

Gary tCS .... didn't know it was you who the comments were sourced from - just thought it was a general naysayer .... apologies for that

The "Smooth" in question was a reference to the Santana (featuring Rob someone) hit record

The point I was trying so ham fistedly to make was - you don't know 'til you try - you yourself have tried and succeeded, however limited the opportunities may be. My point to the OP was that the whole moan about different stuff was succinctly dealt with by Egbert and his comment regarding using excuses.






Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 12:26 (GMT)

@Willow - no worries, and no 'smooth' is generally not appealing to me when describing alternative genres. I often use the phrase 'sugar coated' which means the same thing. And yes Egbert made a very good point......"giving it to the bar staff tour" - I like that. Haha.


Avatar
 
# Posted by ST Photography - VIVA LA COMMU... - 13/09/2011, 12:53 (GMT)

We need to be careful here. There's a danger that anyone who expresses an opinion that is controversial get's labelled a troll or a dalek. That was always going to happen after more recent events, so it's something we should all be mindful of.

That said, I actually find myself agreeing with some of what 4most Wanted has said. Of course, if you're not happy playing music you don't love, you should seek other ventures. In an ideal world, everyone would be playing the music they love to the people who love it. But this is the real world folks and some people have to get by by compromising. Such is life.

Further to that, It's been said a thousand times before, classic rock is still the most popular genre in terms of bands, venues and fans but in my humble opinion, it's been overdone. However, there is always a flip side to the argument. I wouldn't normally go out and watch a band advertised as "classic rock" unless they had been recommended. But that's just my taste. Ocassionally you will come across a classic rock band that blows you away and opens up a whole new avenue to your listening preference (in my case it was Black Rose).

And so, in summary, it is indeed horses for courses.

Asa


Avatar
 
# Posted by Synthy Mike - 13/09/2011, 14:20 (GMT)

I think it's a catch-22 situation really. Classic Rock is definately the prominent genre of music on these pages, certainly out of frequency of postings anyway and more classic rock gigs get listed on NWB than any other genre. People obviously like the stuff or venues wouldn't be putting it on!

Having played in a great classic rock band, I found that I didn't grow tired of the music per-say. I'll admit I did get a bit bored playing the "stalwarts" every week but the irony was those songs were the ones people in the crowd liked the most! However, the main reason I stopped doing the classic rock stuff was that I didn't enjoy the act of gigging every Friday and Saturday really - even though it gave me quite a bit of extra money each week. I could've been playing all my favourite tunes of all time, with the gigging schedule I had it would've still been a chore to me. I missed going out with my mates and spending time with the Mrs, plus I wanted to try something completely different and have a pop at doing something original.

I've never been a huge live music fan. Of course gigging can be an amazing experience but I much prefer creating it. I'm not even that keen on watching the bands I like really, most of the time I prefer to listen to a band's albums than go to see them in concert. I must be a weirdo!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 13/09/2011, 14:26 (GMT)

Mike - interesting that ........ i sometimes find myself these days happier rehearsing and pissing about rather than actually gigging (still only sometimes tho!!) - and the number of gigs i've been to watch (both pro and semi pro) has been reducing drastically
I reckon it's me age .......... last few years I've been more than happy with no more than 26 gigs a year .... I can even see that reducing now!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by ST Photography - VIVA LA COMMU... - 13/09/2011, 14:28 (GMT)

Not wierd at all Mike. Just goes to show that not everything is black and white and it takes all sorts.

"Everybody's born to do a certain thing
and if you're dead jammy you find it.
And if you're good at it just keep doing it
until you're fed up then do something else.
You're here to make babies and look after the place.
You know ?" (Billy Connolly)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Synthy Mike - 13/09/2011, 14:44 (GMT)

@Willow - I think for me less is definately more with gigs, I find I really get that excitement back when there's been a gap of a few weeks (maybe more) and I agree about rehearsals - they're great... though that might be because there's an amazing kebab shop across the road from where we rehearse! But it's great to faff around, come up with silly ideas and just tinker, as well as running through the songs! I love rehearsing at the tail end of the week, sets me up in a good mood for the weekend.

@ST - I think that's bang on for me really (apart from the babies bit - rather a daunting thought). I can't envision ever doing the same thing for years on end, being a Rolling Stone would be my idea of musical hell - well apart from the fat tax-evaded bank balance associated with it!


Avatar
 
# Posted by ~ THE SUG4R BULLETS ~ - 13/09/2011, 14:45 (GMT)

Just been watching a few vids on the ol' Tube, came across a mass 10 page debate starting with the usual 'what is Punk?' then onto a more general discussion about music, tastes, personal preferences, one man's hell is another man's heaven etc etc....

Then I came across this comment and BOOOM:

"only fucking retards label music"

Brilliant I thought...


Avatar
 
# Posted by Synthy Mike - 13/09/2011, 14:53 (GMT)

@Sugar Bullets - Bang on! It's obviously quite difficult not to pigeonhole music but I think in reality there's only two labels you need with music "good" and "rubbish" (or a less polite choice of word). Obviously completely subjective but lets be honest, it's the biggest deciding factors we all have when chosing what we want to listen to or play!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Havoc 51 - 13/09/2011, 14:55 (GMT)

I can understand a lot of what the OP is on about as I'm guessing we're the same age and have similar musical backgrounds.

I grew up with the ZEP, Purple, Quo, Queen, Sabbaths etc. I burned through more vynil copies of made in Japan as a kid (inbetween proper lessons) than I care to recall. In my teens I was all over the place playing gigs from back alley dives to much larger venues, made a fair amount with some bands, lost a fair amount with others.

For me with age comes clarity. As a kid I'd get all irate if the guitarist in the band at my local venue played in pentatonic boxes, let alone not as per the original track. Nowadays it's more like, fk it there's only probably me noticed and as the punters like it who cares. I accept there are easily a dozen Kylies/Gagas etc who can do the generic shite, but there's only one Plant/Mercury/Jimmi etc. So you aren't going to see a replica. I've yet to see a decent Zep tribute

And it's that subtle difference which keeps me playing. I'm playing for other peoples enjoyment, not to get joy from fretwanking or right handed techniques that I'd get a stiffy from. I do that in the 20 odd hours a week doing scales & modes and from playing along with certain tracks that do it for me. Plus get into writing and recording, there's a lot to get from that.

Yes there have been and still are some bands that are simply crap, and shouldn't be doing it, but believe me there's a lot fewer of them now as you can't get away with it like you could. I've dropped tens of tracks from our rehersals as we can;t do justice to them, I'm sore most bands on here do.

Simply for me it's this. Play for the enjoyment of your audience or don't bother.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Havoc 51 - 13/09/2011, 14:55 (GMT)

oooops double post


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 18:00 (GMT)

@Havoc 51 - Play for the enjoyment of your audience or don't bother

Interesting point and one which is shared by a lot of people on here. However, I personally get a real kick from people approaching me at the end of the night and saying "I don't like the blues but I really enjoyed what you did there - have you got any cds?"

If you only play to the audience in front of you then you never hear comments like that.....go on be daring! ;-) hehe


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 13/09/2011, 20:26 (GMT)

whilst i, in general, agree wholeheartedly with "sugar bullets" comment-for the purposes of discussion i'm going to ask the question anyway......

could someone please tell me what is meant by "classic rock"? i thought i knew-apparently i am mistaken (for example-"real excess" (ex-"rock radio") radio claims to play "classic rock" yet i hear tunes on there that in no way, to me, are recognisably "classic rock"?)


plus-to offer another side of the debate-i have seen, possibly, hundreds of musos over the years as a member of the much mentioned but -as far as i can see in the debates on here over the months-never consulted, "audiences"-and in my opinion some musos clearly display a singular lack of enthusiasm or enjoyment for what they play and that feeds into the audience response. the majority, however, DO, for that time they are "up there and playing", display a love of music and what they play-they could be damn good actors-who knows?-that is not the point-that being that if a muso doesn't enjoy the type of music they play they SHOULD NOT BE PLAYING IT!!!

it does a grave disservice,it seems to me, to the people who attend gigs to be faced by a lacklustre display of boredom when they are out to -more likely than not- gain some respite from their weekly stress or troubles by way of listening to music that they like for a few hours or so and go home having their spirits lifted by that music played by musos who can connect with them..




Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 13/09/2011, 23:32 (GMT)

@Viking - good points but surely only aimed at those who play music for a hobby. Although I choose to play the styles of music which appeal to me I also take 'jobs' for the money as well. The difference is that you won't notice when I'm bored because-

a) a proffessional attitude will mean that my playing is not sloppy (not intentionally anyway)

b) yes I can act a bit as well!

Now, if you ask everyone on here if they have 100% job satisfaction I'm sure that the numbers would be very very low in the yes camp but you wouldn't suggest that people don't go to work.

As for classic rock, well I think that you know very well what classic rock is. The same as I know what the blues is but it doesn't stop The Animals & Friends from playing at Colne Blues Festival!


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 14/09/2011, 16:22 (GMT)

Ok, I really didn’t want to get into a slanging match with anybody, but since one or two on here insist on being knob jockeys………………….

@Blackjacks – Self indulgent? So wanting to do something a bit more interesting than a 3 chord trick or a brain killing, incredibly dull, plodding bass line is self indulgent eh! It’s exactly that stupid fucking attitude that made me post the blog. And travel all over the North West playing jazz eh? Of course that’s a viable economical solution isn’t it? You must be a guitarist, as clearly you don’t engage your brain before opening your mouth. Reality check perhaps?

@Sugarbullets - "only fucking retards label music" – Great comment that from somebody who label themselves as “Punk Tribute Act”. Does that mean you are a fucking retard because you’ve labelled your particular genre? But surely, only fucking retards would want to keep playing the same mind numbingly, unspeakably dull, monotonous music week in, week out?

@Egbert and Willow – Yes, I want to do something different, but if you think it’s that easy, you’re clearly from the same stable as the morons above. I am not using any other bands inertia as my excuse for not playing. I AM saying if you don’t want to play the typical genres of classic rock, indie rock, blues or punk, you’re pretty fucked in the North West, as in my experience, there are neither the musicians or the venues that cater for anything different. And yes, I am looking further afield.

As Cottonhouse Shakers and Mr. Nobody have pointed out, the problem is finding like minded musicians who don’t want to play “the norm”. I have met a good few musicians in the past 12 months, who have all said they want something different but are all blessed with an abundance of apathy. From those who can’t be arsed travelling to those who can’t be arsed rehearsing or learning anything new.

And try finding a guitarist that DOESN’T want to be a plank wanker! There is only a handful that actually exist, I’m sure of it.

Then there are those who think you’ve got to do the standards to get the gigs. And it goes on.

Again, as Cottonhouse Shakers has stated, (and thanks for the heads up on The Giddy Gringos by the way), “None of my bands are particularly busy, which is why I play in so many different line ups”, which is great if it happens. To be honest, I envy you.

Of course, I could probably start a band tomorrow doing all the things I hate, but that would be selling out wouldn’t it? Hypocritical at best, and absolutely fucking soul destroying.

So in answer to a couple of the ridiculous comments:
“If you don’t like it, don’t do it”………….. Erm yes, I think I’ve covered that one.
"If you want to do something different to most of the bands on here then do it”…………. Erm, which part of the “muso’s not available” comments do you not understand?

Love and moisture always,

Mark


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 16:55 (GMT)

Liking the love, keep the moisture

So what you're saying is there are only the 20 to 30 musicians that make up Gary's (tCS) 7 bands in the whole of the North West - there's none left for you to join up with???
No-one said it was easy (Yes, I said s'easy, meaning the get up and do it) ...... usually nothing worthwhile is ever easy ......

I didn't think the original comment was at all controversial or elitist, just a bit whiney

You quote "the problem is finding like minded musicians who don’t want to play “the norm”. then say you're envious of Gary tCS for playing in "so many different line ups”

Good luck




Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 14/09/2011, 17:28 (GMT)

@Willow - "So what you're saying is there are only the 20 to 30 musicians that make up Gary's (tCS) 7 bands in the whole of the North West - there's none left for you to join up with??? - None that I've found or heard of anyway.

"No-one said it was easy (Yes, I said s'easy, meaning the get up and do it) ...... usually nothing worthwhile is ever easy ...... - I'd love to get up and do it, IF, I could find others who could be arsed.

"I didn't think the original comment was at all controversial or elitist, just a bit whiney" Your answer to anyone who "whines" is always the same - "don't do it then - it's easy". If only everything in life was as simple as you make it out to be.

"You quote "the problem is finding like minded musicians who don’t want to play “the norm”. then say you're envious of Gary tCS for playing in "so many different line ups” - I am envious of Gary's diversity, his reason for playing in 7 different bands. At the moment I'd settle for one band that didn't have a plank wanker who wants to do "a slow blues in G" or anything from the NWB set list top 50.

The best lesson I ever got in music was to "express" rather than "impress". Try passing that lesson on to the "rawk gawds" of the north west. I honestly cannot take any of them seriously since I saw Spinal Tap.



Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 18:03 (GMT)

i find it hard to believe that there are only a handful of musicians who would meet your brief and that you can't find them .......... HOWEVER .... i'm not the one looking for them so I have to take your word for it.

I still wish you the best of luck


Avatar
 
# Posted by Tubthumper - 14/09/2011, 18:14 (GMT)

Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 18:17 (GMT)

The Portlands???????????????!!!!!!!!!!!

LOLOLOLOL

Won't mean anything to you Nic (or 4most) I don't think .... but that's sooooooooooo funny given what went on a few months ago!!

Good sounds tho - I like 'em .........


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 14/09/2011, 18:35 (GMT)

@the cottonhouse shakers-indeed, dude- referring to those who only(!!) play for the love of music-those who are professionals, as you rightly point out, will, usually, "put on a show" regardless of other factors and do,of course, have to sometimes put on a brave face-however-. in my experience pro's generally tend to diversify in their playing on a circuit (as you do?)? don't stick to the same genre? ( a generalisation, i know-but purely for the sake of clarity).


again-for clarity-no one was being singled out in my comment.

i'm not asserting that every one must express "job satisfaction" 100% of the time- that would be disingenous and somewhat silly. further-isn't the subject matter under discussion regarding playing for pleasure as opposed to "work"? i am merely opining that-if playing in front of an audience doesn't give one pleasure then it is,indeed, time to call it a day-or perhaps find a more suitable alternative vehicle for one's musical expression? no matter how professional one may be-if the "spark" has gone out when one is up on stage it, more often than not, shows in the presentation of the music and is readily picked up on by an audience.

how many times have we read blogs on here reviewing gigs by very well known musos reporting that the "star" in question was giving a lacklustre performance time after time-as if they didn't want to be there. that, in my opinion, is not a good way to treat the people who have gone to watch (whether paying or not).

as for "knowing very well what "classic rock is"-i thought i did-apparently it encompasses a far wider range of music than i had originally believed-perhaps i'm just not keeping up with the times?

i will bow to your greater experience on this(genuinely!)-however-colne blues festival has always had a well deserved reputation for putting on an eclectic range of artists and musicians-encompassing a wide variety of blues based music, has it not?-and "the animals" fall neatly into that category, if memory serves me well? whereas kings of leon, foo fighters, sixties pop/rock, arctic monkeys and the like most certainly are not, in my view, "classic rock"!!! others seem to have a different view.


the main thrust of my comment was (and still is) to remind that there is a symbiotic element to music-audiences have feelings too!!


p.s. @ 4most wanted-i,also, wish you well in your quest-you seem to have a passion for what you want to do or play-that is never a bad thing, in my opinion. ;-D


Avatar
 
# Posted by ~ THE SUG4R BULLETS ~ - 14/09/2011, 19:17 (GMT)

The 'labelling' comment was in regards to, as Synthy Mike said, "good" and "rubbish", not the type/genre of music. Others understood so who's the fucking retard now?

All you've done since your dalek ass signed up here is moan like a fucking baby...don't you ever have anything positive or constructive to say? Perhaps you've not quite grasped the concept that this site is for people who share a common acceptance of each other's bands, different abilities and preferences.

You remind me of a guy I used to play football with, a great commentator but did fuck all on the pitch!


Avatar
 
# Posted by LAST GANG IN TOWN - 14/09/2011, 19:29 (GMT)

Dean...you on about Wick...he he he...


Avatar
 
# Posted by ~ THE SUG4R BULLETS ~ - 14/09/2011, 20:11 (GMT)

Haha...nah not our Wick, he's like lightening on that pitch.


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 14/09/2011, 20:16 (GMT)

@ the sugar bullets- a bit like - ermmm- a gazelle, by any chance?? ;-D


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 14/09/2011, 20:31 (GMT)

Bang on V - have you seen him PMSL

AYP


Avatar
 
# Posted by ~ THE SUG4R BULLETS ~ - 14/09/2011, 20:31 (GMT)

Mmm more like speedy gonzales...

Here's one for ya's:

What does Speedy Gonzales use to lay his carpets?

Underlay underlay!


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 14/09/2011, 20:49 (GMT)

@alyerpal-nahh, bro-but i've seen willow's "pre-match picture" of him (a case of....ruminating cloven hooved horned species for sporting events?);-D

@ sugar bullets-GROOANN!! lol!! :-D


BLOGJACK!!!! yayyy!! ;-D


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 14/09/2011, 21:06 (GMT)

I think Deanio needs to get his poncho......

That one's older than me!

AYP


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 21:09 (GMT)

he needs to get on the bus ................

arriva arriva

poncho, saddle and stirrups got!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 14/09/2011, 21:10 (GMT)

@alyerpal- "(a case of....ruminating cloven hooved horned species for sporting events?)";-D


did you see what i did there?kept to the blog subject!!!! ;-D


Avatar
 
# Posted by ~ THE SUG4R BULLETS ~ - 14/09/2011, 21:23 (GMT)

Making signs since 1932!


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 14/09/2011, 21:47 (GMT)

@Sugarbullets – Quite clearly mate, you are exactly the kind of moron I keep complaining about.
I’ve stated on more than one occasion that the NW music scene is dying on it’s arse, because plebs like you refuse to accept change. Plebs like you that are one dimensional, trying to keep alive something that died over 30 fucking years ago. That’s what punk was all about then, being fresh, exciting and non-conventional. But like you, it’s all gone incredibly stale and exceedingly dull.

And yes, I have a lot of positive and constructive things to say, especially about artists who are experimental and original, but unfortunately not for those who are devoid of any imagination or originality, such as yourself or any number of uninspiring cover bands around at the moment.

So this site is for those with a common acceptance of each other’s bands eh? That’s right. Because unless you’re willing to blow smoke up everyone else’s arse, you’re not accepted into the clique. And God forbid any of those who question the very fabric of what you’ve built your community on eh? And God forbid those who have an opinion that doesn’t quite sit right with the “establishment”.

For fuck’s sake, I would have thought you, as a so called punk, would appreciate that. I thought acceptance and conformance was the very thing punks fought against. So you sound like a plastic punk to me.

And one of the best quotes I’ve ever heard , and one which some of you lot need shoving up your arses, comes from Willow.
“Ultimately you're as good or as shit as you wanna be ...but woe betide you when you start to believe you're half as good as you're not!!

Spot on that. And describes you lot perfectly.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 21:56 (GMT)

its not about acceptance(and shouldnt be), far from it, its about respecting someone elses opinion, whether you agree or completely disagree, i see many things on here that anger me and i completely do not understand, although i dont deem it necessary to resort to name calling,especially if its somebody i havent even met,and wouldnt say to them in person, ive had some healthy debates with a few people on here and theyve all become friends, i respect strong opinions and outspoken views, but i know where the line is

surely not worth arguing over this stuff is it really?, try the Lebowski approach, works for me :0)

best wishes
Rob


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 22:44 (GMT)

Did I say that??? Wow!! I like it!
consider it copyrighted - intellectual property rights an' all that

LOL


Avatar
 
# Posted by Defunct account - 14/09/2011, 22:52 (GMT)

@4 mostwanted

I would suggest you read my post again. You'll note (clue is in parenthesis following my name) I play in an originals band - a band and a "scene" quite often held up to ridicule on this very forum. You would perhaps also note that I say that we have managed to cram in 300+ gigs in just over 2 and a bit years. My point was given that number of gigs and given that we do do something VERY different to most of the bands on here that there are plenty of opportunities to do something different to "the norm" in the north west.

Just before getting back to this thread I noticed a Bright Shapes posting. Another originals band doing something very different to the "accepted NWB norm" - would suggest you listen to the song they posted a link to. They too are getting through a raft of gigs - but unlike us they attract mainly favourable response on this board from those, err "plebs" ;-) - as are plenty of others.

What sort of stuff you looking to do? Perhaps there are others on here who might think hang on, I like that, bad start but lets give this fella a shout.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 22:58 (GMT)

the reason i still come on this site is that ive made many great friends through a shared love of music, not some kinda classic rock clique etc etc and if im totally honest about 75 percent of my facebook friends are there from music

re the blog subject....LOL it would take a great band for me to go out especially and watch, but with that comment i am taking nothing away from any bands starting up, eg young uns that have only been playing for 6 months(weve all started there) and i completely admit my favourite genre is classic rock, if i hear another dicey version of alright now i may throw up in my mouth but i still dont wanna take anything away from any band doing very common songs, i still love to hear THOSE songs and i too have played some of those songs (guilty as charged),havent we all, i too search to hear something new when im out watching on a busmans, would some more bands please do more 90s alt rock for example, alice in chains,Red hot chilis, pearl jam etc!

if i take anything from this blog and discussion my own take on it would be thus

wanna do a free song?

do fire and water instead of wishing well

a queen song?

do keep yourself alive instead of crazy little thing called love

etc etc

if youre really honest about wanting a break from the norm im sure youd be surprised there is a lot of people of the same mindset out there


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 14/09/2011, 23:05 (GMT)

I just knew you were going to be boring.

I don't actually understand why you put this blog on in the first place.

I love a good debate and I love a good argument, but you don't want to do either, Not only are you derogative of other peoples opinions, you are rude and personal aswell. You don't want to enter into any sort of conversation: you have made your point and you are sticking to it.

So why make any statement on an open forum in the first place? Why make the opening ganbit of 'possibly controversial, but that's just me' when what you actually meant was 'here's my opinion and if you don't like it you are a moron'.

You had a pop at me for wanting to make a living out of helping my fellow musicians look as good as possible with my business and for trying to be part of a community 'Apologies that this blog is not advertising your business, or praising your workmanship, but hey, they can't all be about you eh?'

Read my blogs before you make sweeping statements like that.

You haven't said anything that contributes to either this site or the people on it.

Inspite of all that, I will remain for the time being

Alyerpal


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 23:11 (GMT)

i can leave a classic cd for a 6 months (eg back in black) cos ive heard it far too much, stick it on again,and get that same rush again, but i must admit theres that big degree of familiarity there(which never slides into contempt though) but its what makes me seek out the newer bands out there to get something new,albeit in the same genre

eg Black Stone Cherry,Alter Bridge,The Answer,Rival Sons,The Union,Reckless Love,HEAT,Saint Jude,The VirginMarys, etc etc


Avatar
 
# Posted by Jez (Route 69) - 14/09/2011, 23:17 (GMT)

@4mostwanted - "I have a lot of positive and constructive things to say, especially about artists who are experimental and original, but unfortunately not for those who are devoid of any imagination or originality, such as yourself or any number of uninspiring cover bands around at the moment."

......I've just read your repertoire on your profile - which bit of it is "inspiring and original" pmsl!!!

If you don't like covers bands dont fuckin watch them - simple!!! I don't like horse racing - but I don't run into the local bookies and wind up the punters!!!

relax....

:0)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 23:22 (GMT)

id like to go into the bookies actually and give random tips on horses haha

"try that one pal, its got a cool name, bollox to the odds"


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 14/09/2011, 23:29 (GMT)

@Egbert - fair play to you for the original stuff mate. I wish you all the luck in the world. Yes I'd love to do original stuff, but as i say, finding the right members is becoming impossible. And also, I know there are a few bands on here trying something different, but I do believe they are the minority. I'm not trying to label every band as rubbish or whatever, I'm saying their attitudes towards anything different is rubbish.

@Rob Redfern - excellent comments mate, I agree entirely. In one of my last projects I mentioned Janes Addiction - Just Because, Creed - My Sacrifice, Pearl Jam - Jeremy....... all got a resounding "not well known enough". So I said, well if we're gonna do Free, what about Little Bit of Love? Or if we 're gonna do Pink Floyd, what about Money? And I really wanted to do Keep Yourself Alive but there's always an excuse why we CAN'T do it.

To be honest, I'm all rocked out and just wanted a complete change. Something I could groove to. And the Latin American thing interests me. As does funk. Bernard Edwards is "The Man" for me at the moment. Currently listening to a black American funkster called Maxwell who's fucking awesome. Love George Benson too. In my opinion, one of the best guitarists in the world. But to go back to the beginning......... horses for courses and all that eh?


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 14/09/2011, 23:32 (GMT)

' “Ultimately you're as good or as shit as you wanna be ...but woe betide you when you start to believe you're half as good as you're not!!

Spot on that. And describes you lot perfectly. '

So what 'lot' are you part of?

Al


Avatar
 
# Posted by TEX & THE HARDCORE TROUBAD... - 14/09/2011, 23:34 (GMT)

Horses fer courses??
yup, we play loadsa stuff that caters fer horses ;-)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 23:43 (GMT)

I think this particular horse has been upended at Beechers and is now lying covered by tarpaulin!!

Medic!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 23:44 (GMT)

its a shame people get all wound up on here(and we are ALL guilty of this, me included) seems people have strong reactions about this music thing, just baffles me why interesting debates on music on here often go silly and get heated, im sure all that make personal insults have some element of hindsight when looking back at what theyve typed in the heat of the moment. i love to see a heated debate, but within half an hour predictably and disappointingly always descends into manure throwing

for a reality check i sometimes show my other half some of the blogs on here(including arguments ive been involved in and /or commented on, to hear "who cares/why such a fuss " etc!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by NIGHT TRAIN - 14/09/2011, 23:44 (GMT)

Can't be bothered reading all this, but seeing its all my fault....must admit there doesn't seem to be much 'creativity' on here, which is odd seeing its a music forum. with musicians posting. I mean, I stick my home produced stuff on quite regular, which I do for my own amusement...ok, nothing earth shattering but at least I'm doing something....

Just out of interest, how many people on here actually do the same? I think it would be really good to see a bit of creative work (instead of all the 16 track recorders for sale :)....was interesting to hear Smitten Kitten's stuff....and would add a new dimension to the site, which, lets face it is dominated by covers bands


Avatar
 
# Posted by Tubthumper - 14/09/2011, 23:49 (GMT)

Medic? Vet, surely.

And for the record, I didn't get wound up once. I agree with absolutely everything everyone said. It's so much easier that way.

...what, what! (that's my new favourite catchphrase - I may even grow a matching twirly moustache).


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 14/09/2011, 23:50 (GMT)

I was scheduled to do "an album a day" in collaboration with some other NWBers but its been postponed.

I can't do original to save me life, but I like doing different(ish) covers .... and have posted a few on here previously to mixed reactions ......... which is great, all reactions are great!!

You've got a start Alec with your blues themed recordings .... i sit there with a blank canvas, and it just gets blanker!! LOL

Maybe i'll try something soon

Definitely agree about posting stuff tho ... altho I do now hesitate to put negative comments (even constructive ones)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Defunct account - 14/09/2011, 23:50 (GMT)

@Alec

In for a penny I guess...

http://soundcloud.com/snofi/swamp-girl-with-krackpot

Is what I'm working on tonight


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 14/09/2011, 23:51 (GMT)

@Alyerpal - I also love a good debate and a good argument, but it wasn't me who started being personal, rude or derogative. I merely made a comment based on my opinion that the whole "scene" is dull and boring. I'm quite open to criticism for making that comment, but like I said, that's just me. Which is why I posted it as horses for courses. Like I said, I didn't want to get into a slanging match, but the "stalwarts" on here, who will not tolerate any kind of criticism gave a typical "knee jerk" reaction. And that's why you react like you do. Because your heads are stuck so far up your arses that you can't see the daylight. Well wake up and smell the coffee pal. And as for contributing to the site and the people on it - does that mean I should start blowing smoke or kissing arse as quite clearly that's your desire?

@Jez C - just what is it you don't understand about previous correspondence? We've been here before, but just for you, here is it again. The "repertoire" was over 2 years ago. I found it dull and uninspiring so I left the band. And I don't like covers bands, hence the reason I don't go and watch them. Now would you like that in braille, semaphore, spoken, written or sign language? As quite obviously, as a "rawk" guitarist, you're having difficulty following the conversation.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Tubthumper - 14/09/2011, 23:53 (GMT)

Don't be hiding your light under a bushel egbert - that song deserves a thread of its own (and a movie soundtrack to go on).


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 14/09/2011, 23:59 (GMT)

breathe and relax people, think Lebowski


Avatar
 
# Posted by Alyerpal - 15/09/2011, 00:03 (GMT)

I ask again:

' “Ultimately you're as good or as shit as you wanna be ...but woe betide you when you start to believe you're half as good as you're not!!

Spot on that. And describes you lot perfectly. '

So what 'lot' are you part of?

Al


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 15/09/2011, 00:03 (GMT)

@4most


...... and for that reason, i'm out ...... !

only tumbleweed from here from now on

toodles


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 15/09/2011, 00:08 (GMT)

........ EXCEPT ..........

Egbert ....... that track is feckin ace!!

over and out


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 15/09/2011, 00:08 (GMT)

@Night Train - or may I call you Alec? or would you prefer Sir Alec? It's all your fault this!!! You've said in 2 paragraphs what i've been trying to say for months! Thank you for shedding light on a dark subject. For what it's worth, I admire you for your original stuff, it's not my particular bag, but I can see what you're doing and why you're doing it. And for that, I have the utmost respect for you.


Avatar
 
# Posted by NIGHT TRAIN - 15/09/2011, 00:14 (GMT)

@ Egbert....yeh thats more like it...bit of music on here instead of pointless arguing about how much do you go out for etc etc etc....
And here's my new one...yeh I know whats wrong with it...however I do actually want it to sound like this, but a touch better, so I'm redoing it tomorrow...like early 60's r & b on an old valve jukebox. It was inspired by our recent trip to the Laverda Owners do at Baskerville Hall..and even mentions the Bike n Hound...hahaha! I'm doing another on Friday which will be quite interesting to people on here, but its a secret for now!














Avatar
 
# Posted by Jez (Route 69) - 15/09/2011, 00:14 (GMT)

@4most - 2 months ago you were asking for bands based on the fact that you knew 75% percent of the NWB top 100 and needed to play!!!

I might be a " "rawk" guitarist having difficulty following conversation", but I've got a good memory - do you want that in semiphore or braille?

http://nwb.co/blog/post/27945/4mostwanted/bass-player-available

choose your own insult mate, I can't be arsed


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 15/09/2011, 00:41 (GMT)

@Alyerpal - I'm the "lot" that doesn't conform so that I can be socially acceptable.
I'm the "lot" that will say it's shite if I think it's shite, and not worry about offending ego's that have been massaged for a decade or so.
I'm the "lot" that actually sacked a band on stage, in the middle of a gig, because of their incompetence, complacency and attitude.
I'm the "lot" trying not to sell my arse and my soul for a few quid so I can become a respectable member of "the community".
Despite what you may think of me, I know there are some extremely talented musicians on this site that are unfortunately a million miles from what they set out to become. Whether it be peer pressure to conform or whatever, it actually breaks my heart to see wasted talent. But if they're happy doing that, then so be it.
But it also breaks my heart when I see extremely average people, bigging themselves up like they're some sort of be all and end all. Hence the quote, "but woe betide you when you start to believe you're half as good as you're not!!"

You're only as good as your last gig. If it's Wembley or MEN Arena, then fair enough, big yourself up a bit. But there are some on this site, that slag off successful musicians, like Coldplay or Oasis to name but two, because it's not their bag.
So they slag off success and that's fair enough, because that's their opinion. But if I slag off mediocrity, I become an "unwelcome" member of this site.
It's fucking laughable.


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 15/09/2011, 00:49 (GMT)

@Jez - Obviously, your memory isn't that good or you wouldn't be repeating yourself.
And professing to know loads of songs isn't exactly saying that's what I want (or need) to play.
And it's actually spelt s-e-m-a-p-h-o-r-e


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 15/09/2011, 00:50 (GMT)

@Jez - but I can see where you've got "semi" from considering you're a "rawk" guitarist


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Kasuals Solid Sixties Musi... - 15/09/2011, 00:51 (GMT)

@4mostwanted

"I'm the "lot" that actually sacked a band on stage, in the middle of a gig, because of their incompetence, complacency and attitude."

Nothing to be proud of my friend, you would have got more respect by finishing the gig then sacking the band, never make yourself look a TWAT on-stage.............

Lee :)


Avatar
 
# Posted by Willow (of somebig™Fish) (Reti... - 15/09/2011, 00:55 (GMT)

4most

44k's sake man lighten up!!

I can't see anyone slagging you off for what you want to do, or what you want to try to do

Put as much effort into doing that as you have into this pointless blog and you never know what you might find

It doesn't make a jot of a difference to your ambition whether folks on here are shit, massaged, brilliant, conformist, complacent or whatever ......

Musically, as in life, some people have to do things for many different reasons, something you yourself alluded to in a previous blog - just get chanelling towards your own goals regardless of anyone else

D'OH!! I'd finished commenting!!


Avatar
 
# Posted by Rob Redfern, Black Rose,more f... - 15/09/2011, 01:02 (GMT)

you could have learnt three or forty more songs in this time dude?


Avatar
 
# Posted by Tubthumper - 15/09/2011, 01:08 (GMT)

Well I for one have gone back to 4most's original post and agree with him (apart from the not accepting beer tokens bit - it's a luxury I can't afford I'm afraid but if I could achieve the same end in a funky band that no one ever saw I would trade in an instant).

I'm IN a "classic" rock band but I too would rather scoop my eyes out with a melon baller than go to see us or any other band in that genre I'm afraid. Yes it makes me a sellout (my words, not my interpretation of anything anyone has contributed) but needs must and there's clearly still a thriving market for it.

It's a debate that's gone round and round on this forum on a cyclical basis and my concern is that it's becoming a beast thats running out of control though misinterpretation of the written "tone".

PS Willow has high blood pressure (its something to do with him getting overexcited that I'd managed to do 2 poos today, or something to do with having tickets to see some sandal wearing bearded hippy type American folk chap) so be gentle on him......he's not in his right mind obviously.


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 15/09/2011, 01:37 (GMT)

@Lee - The Kasuals - Sorry Lee, but I have to disagree with you on that. The gig in question was an ongoing "jam night". And I also got more plaudits for my actions than I ever did for my playing! From the landlord saying, "i'm glad you did that before I did", to the punters saying it's the best thing they've ever seen.
For the record, I took a new band there the week after and was made to feel like a god. And subsequently, over the following weeks,the audience members doubled as did the band's fee. So result I'd say.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Steve Slinger - 15/09/2011, 14:38 (GMT)

Yawn.


Avatar
 
# Posted by The Cottonhouse Shakers - 16/09/2011, 11:56 (GMT)

@Viking - yes agreed, don't take my pedantic streak too seriously. As for the Animals v's the blues comment, that was a light hearted dig of which I have slapped my own wrist.


Avatar
 
# Posted by viking - 16/09/2011, 20:01 (GMT)

@the cottonhouse house shakers-no offence taken, dude-is always a pleasure to enter into a debate with you-i reckon, perhaps, we may have more in common than first meets the eye? ;-D


Avatar
 
# Posted by Bad Horsie (Mick) - 16/09/2011, 21:31 (GMT)

Looks like I came back from holiday and missed absolutely nothing. Still the same old vague generalisations and buttons pushed.

"I sacked a band from ***** because they weren't cutting it and the landlord of ****** agreed with me. Troll bingo. Lmao.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Wagontown - 16/09/2011, 21:35 (GMT)

Ha Ha good to see ya back Mick,i thought youd popped yer clogs....T


Avatar
 
# Posted by Bad Horsie (Mick) - 16/09/2011, 21:38 (GMT)

Cheers Terry. Not gone. Just went South (US) for a couple of weeks :oD

Gator sausage in New Orleans. It's the TRUTH.


Avatar
 
# Posted by Drum Bloke™ - that bloke that... - 17/09/2011, 16:21 (GMT)

Post 101!

Not too late for a bit of input?

Just read the blog, but not all the posts. So apologies if anything i put here has already been covered

1. Now then the music written and recorded by Zeppelin et al is still and will prove to be some of the greatest rock tunes you will hear, not through judgement but by peoples reaction to them. The World over...
You will find yuor self listening to it again.
I ventured through the styles ( I still listen to anything) right through Rock, Metal, Prog, Funk, Reggae, Jazz Fusion Avantgarde.

2. I take from the comment 'after hearing them being played so badly' you refer to the cover bands in the venues, I don't think this is a reflection on the bands more of yourself and your maturity as a musician.
Besides a musician and a band has to START somewhere... there's no reason either 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 odd year olds cannot be allowed to 'murder' songs in front of the public.
Music is an Art form and beyond control of regulations, standards and 'OPINIONS' ..there are no rules in music.

4. If you would rather play (practicing new technique and trying new musical styles) with yourself then fine, you'll probably end being the best guitarist you'll ever hear.
I know some fantastic musicians who will never join a band again. But rather like painting cooking for yourself isn't it.

5. Good luck in your new venture / search. But in the meantime you may want to keep your hand with playing so like most people I know from time time you will may yourself needing to play a style your not too chuffed about, so don't burn all your bridges eh :)


Avatar
 
# Posted by 4most Wanted - 17/09/2011, 22:21 (GMT)

@Drum Bloke - many thanks for your comments mate. Possibly the most constructive and positive that were fed back.
Point 1 - Dead right. It's just me mate. Nothing against Jimmy and Robert but it just doesn't do it for me anymore. Everybody on here says you should stop playing when you get bored with it. And I got bored with it.
So instead of everyone saying "fair play mate", I'm a moaning cunt who doesn't contribute anything to this site!

Point 2 - Dead right again. I know everybody has to start somewhere and I try to convey that to the students I teach. But I meant to say I wouldn't go out of my way to see a band playing all the old "classics". I really don't mind watching an inexperienced band, as long as they're tight and the sound doesn't make your ears bleed! After all, how are you supposed to gain experience if you don't gig? And I always try to help them by offering them the benefit of my 25+ years experience. But there's nothing worse than seeing a sloppy band, doing a great song really badly. Again, just my opinion but again, according to others on this site, that makes me an elitist and a snobby cunt. But it's just my opinion.

Point 3 - you missed that!! So onto..............................

Point 4 - Actually, yes, I do indeed get more satisfaction by "jamming" along to my favourite songs alone. For me, it's a far better feeling than playing a song you don't like in a place you don't want to be. Unlike others, I don't crave the attention of being on a stage. I'll get back to gigging as and when I'm ready. Providing of course, there are still gigs to be had. At the rate we're going, there'll be nothing left!!

Point 5 - Thank you again for your best wishes, it really is appreciated. I really am trying to keep my hand in, but as arrogant as it sounds, this time it has to be on my terms. I've spent the last 20 years learning songs that other egomaniacs wanted to cover. And I've always gone along with it for the general well being of the band. But whenever I asked a guitarist to sing a song I wanted to play bass on, there was always a reason why they wouldn't/couldn't do it. So I've adopted the attitude of many of the guitarists I've played with over the years, which is "play what I want to play or fuck off". And guess what? That's right............ I'm the cunt!!

As I said, damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Hopefully I'll try and get out and see your band. It would be nice to have a pint with someone as unbiased and fair minded as yourself.

Thanks again and best regards,

Mark


back to top

Blog Search

Follow NWB on Facebook and Twitter

Cottam Guitars

10% Discount for NWB members, email max@cottamguitars.co.uk

Bakehouse Studio

Accrington's cosy project studio. Book online 24/7. Use code NWB20bc110301 for NWB members special 20% discount.

Community Blog Guidelines

  1. Be nice: Even if you disagree with someone, you need to keep your tone civil and reasonable.
  2. Keep on topic: Please keep discussions relevant to each topic and avoid multiple topic posts.
  3. Don't Spam: Show restraint with your posting frequency. We're all doing cool stuff on NWB, but if we post about it too much, it can be distracting.
  4. Respect the Moderators: The entire Community Staff were users once, just like you. We try very hard to answer everyone's questions, so please be cool.

PAT Testing

Pat Testing NW
Mention NWB when contacting